The Mexico Disaster of 1886
Research by Jacqueline Arundel
RNLI History 1886: Southport and St Annes lifeboats disaster
This rescue remains the worst loss of crew in a single incident in RNLI history and was viewed as a national disaster across Victorian England.
The Mexico, a 400 ton Hamburg barque, left Liverpool on 5 December 1886 bound for Guayaquil, Ecuador. Four days later she was caught in a violent gale and amidst heavy seas and snow showers she ran aground on the perilous sandbanks in the Ribble Estuary near Southport. Lifeboats were launched from Lytham, St Annes and Southport to rescue the stranded crew.
Eliza Fernley from Southport and Laura Janet from St Annes were the first lifeboats to launch. Tragically, they both capsized during the rescue attempt and 27 of the 29 crew were drowned. A third lifeboat, Charles Biggs, launched on its maiden rescue, saved the Mexico’s 12 crew members.
Southport’s Eliza Fernley was the first lifeboat to be launched in response to the Mexico’s distress signals. As the Eliza Fernley reached the stricken vessel the rough seas and terrible gale capsized her. Only 2 of the 16 crew survived, Henry Robinson and John Jackson, who had been trapped under the boat after it overturned. They survived by clinging to the keel of the boat and swimming back to shore to raise the alarm. Two hours later the lifeboat was found washed up at Birkdale.
Twenty minutes after the Eliza Fernley was called out, the Laura Janet from St Annes was launched. It never reached the Mexico and was found ashore the following morning – the entire crew had been lost. As there were no survivors it has never been clear exactly what happened to the Laura Janet.
A third lifeboat, the Charles Biggs, was launched on her maiden rescue to assist the crew of the Mexico. After shattering 3 oars and being filled numerous times with water, the Lytham crew, in their new vessel, miraculously reached the stricken ship. By this point the Mexico had settled on her beam ends and her crew had strapped themselves to the rigging. The Charles Biggs rowed for a mile and a half to reach the Mexico and successfully rescued all 12 crew members.
This was the worst disaster in RNLI history; 27 men lost, leaving 16 widows and 50 children without fathers. A public appeal was launched to support those widowed and orphaned by the tragedy. Donations were received from Queen Victoria and Kaiser Wilhelm.
The money raised also went towards memorials to commemorate the lifeboatmen lost at sea. Six memorials were erected, including on the promenade at St Annes, Duke Street Cemetery in Southport and St Cuthbert’s Church in Lytham, which still stands today.
On 23 May 1888 the Lifeboat Monument was unveiled in St Annes to commemorate the bravery of these crews.
An 1891 appeal, bolstered by the press in the north-east of England, raised £10,000 in just two weeks. In the same year a local businessman, Sir Charles Macara, and his wife, Marion, organised Lifeboat Saturday, the first recorded charity street collection. It featured a parade of bands, floats and lifeboats through the streets of Manchester and raised over £5,000. Marion Macara formed a Ladies’ Guild to help organise the street collection and within 10 years more than 40 Ladies’ Guilds had sprung up around Britain and Ireland, helping to double the RNLI’s income.
Next door to Lytham Windmill is The Old Lytham Lifeboat House; constructed largely of cobblestones these are a feature of many Lytham buildings. The Shipwrecked Mariners Society, later replaced by the RNLI, first stationed a lifeboat at Lytham in 1851 and the twelve lifeboats that have been stationed in Lytham over the years have saved hundreds of lives.
For many years the Old Lifeboat House was a museum, telling the story of Lytham lifeboats from 1851 to the present day. The Grade II listed building closed in 2004 but reopened to the public after over 10 years of closure. The main exhibit is a Victorian Pulling and Sailing Lifeboat named Chapman that has recently been restored to a very high level. The theme of the museum is the Great Lifeboat Disaster of 1886.
The museum was organised by Lytham Heritage Group who already managed the adjacent museum inside Lytham Windmill.
The Group worked in close partnership with Lytham St Annes
RNLI Heritage Team and Fylde Borough Council.
THE CREW OF THE LAURA JANET
lost on the night of 9/10 December 1886
William Johnson, 35 (Coxswain)
Charles Tims, 43 (2nd Coxswain)
Oliver Hodson, 39 (Bowman)
James Bonney, 21
Nicholas Parkinson, 22
Richard Fisher, 45
James Johnson, 45
John P Wignall 22
Reuben Tims, 30
Thomas Parkinson 28,
Thomas Bonney, 35
James Dobson, 23
James Harrison, 19
THE CREW OF THE SOUTHPORT LIFEBOAT ELIZA FERNLEY
lost on the night of 9/10 December 1886
Charles Hodge (Coxswain)
Ralph Peters (2nd Coxswain)
The above details were taken from:
On Those Infernal Ribble Banks - A Record of Lifesaving by the Lifeboats of Lytham St Annes by David Forshaw, 2nd edition,
published for and on behalf of Lytham St Annes RNLI Station by Great Northern Publishing, 2006
Several poems were written about the Mexico disaster, the most famous being by Clement Scott, 1886, the Poet Laureate, entitled 'The Warriors of the Sea'. This is reproduced in full in the above book.